| 125 - | Joey Schwartz (WU) > Dave Colagiovanni (Cortland), DEC 5-3 |
| 133 - | Brian Bistis (Cortland) > Omar Santiago (Oswego), DEC 3-0 |
| 141 - | Aljamian Sterling (Cortland) > Chris Payne (Oswego), DEC 3-1 |
| 149 - | Isaac Dukes (CWRU) > Default David Malkus (JCU), FALL 1:58 |
| 157 - | Troy Sterling (Cortland) > Nick Rodgers (Oswego), DEC 4-3 |
| 165 - | John Conroy (Cortland) > Clarence Semple (JCU), DEC 10-6 |
| 174 - | Andrew Scavuzzo (BWC) > Todd Gaydosh (JCU), DEC 5-1 |
| 184 - | Jefferson Ajayi (WU) > Joe Georgian (BWC), DEC 3-2 |
| 197 - | Carl Korpi (Cortland) > Tristan Stoll (BWC), DEC 4-2 |
| 285 - | Corey James (Cortland) > Ryan Jones (BWC), DEC 3-0 |